Update, put it all back together and put it over the chrono. Dissapointing result. Still putting out 9 ft.lbs, but boy is it smooth and quiet. There was very little preload on the new spring so maybe i need to shim one end. The same recoil as my HW 97K which was tuned by Dave Hall of Bonnie and Clyde. If i remember correctly the 22 Eclipse used to have a piston wieght in it, my one has no spacers either end. I still have some piston weights from years ago i may put one in to see if there is a difference. One of the stock screws broke so i need to replace that as well. Oh well back to the drawing board.